Michael S Roth @mroth78

16th president @Wesleyan_u, (grand)father, husband, author, professor. Opinions my own. Advocate for pragmatic #LiberalArts #LiberalEducationMatters #GoWes

Recent quotes:

‘Unearthed’ Review: A Holocaust Story Kept Secret - WSJ

History is written, we’d like to believe, from the impulse to create a record of the past that is as accurate as possible. More frequently, I suspect, history is written for some personal or political purpose in the present. Sometimes, though,we turn to the past from an obligation to preserve what we care about from the oblivion of forgetting—expressing a form of piety.

The Christian Liberal-Arts School at the Heart of the Culture Wars | The New Yorker

“I do think it’s a mistake to imagine that the Western tradition necessarily leads to the discovery of truth with a capital ‘T.’ You can only do that if you ignore a lot of the world.” Reading storied texts to justify your views as an American or a Christian or an inheritor of the classical tradition—“that also is a way of justifying your own parochialism,”

What’s the State of Free Expression on Campus?

You need thoughtful approaches that allow for dissension, disagreement, resilience building — and for self-censorship! I don’t know what’s so bad about self-censorship. Queer people, Black people, and Jews have been doing this. I had to sit here and listen to you guys talk about salvation and sinners and that every religion has a sense of — That’s not true! As a Jew — I can’t believe I’m saying that; usually I self-censor. And now white middle-class people have begun to self-censor. Not so bad!

Universities must resist DeSantis’ overreach | Times Higher Education (THE)

We don’t need the government to tell college students and their teachers what to think or what they can study. All members of a campus community should feel that they can enter into controversy without fear of being silenced or constrained. A commitment to the free exchange of ideas and pursuit of knowledge involves a wide range of protections for speech and expression, even when noxious or offensive. This commitment does not allow for interventions by government into what values must guide research.

Deconstruction Isn’t Dead

The sober recognition that truth and facts are socially constructed, thus historically and culturally contingent, likewise forces scholars to consider the way systems of knowledge change or differ across space and time and thus are not cast in stone. The diagnosis of systems of power and the role they play in determining which subjects, truths, and facts are privileged and which are not, likewise provides an entrance into analysis, critique, resistance, or support.

Gun Control Live Updates: Senate Vote and Supreme Court Ruling - The New York Times

The majority opinion announced a general standard by which courts must now judge restrictions on gun rights: “The government must demonstrate that the regulation is consistent with this nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.”

Book review of A Brief History of Equality by Thomas Piketty - The Washington Post

Vast and cruel destruction of life and property, Piketty once wrote, was the critical prelude to the 20th century’s social democratic triumph. Let us hope the world will not require similar death and despair to thrust into existence a 21st-century era of economic and social reconstruction.

A college president responds to the rioters at the U.S. Capitol (opinion)

we in higher education must recommit to encouraging the kind of democratic practice that is fully in sync with the goals of liberal education: habits of discussion, compromise, collective aspiration and care for the vulnerable. Our students and colleagues have planted those seeds, our neighbors have nurtured them and I am confident in the harvest. Weeding out outrage and resentment and nourishing what we sow with common purpose, we will make democracy bountiful for our communities and for our country. This is work we must do or watch it all be blown away in some idiot wind.

Alito’s Plan to Repeal Roe—and Other 20th Century Civil Rights - The Atlantic

Alito’s writing reflects the current tone of right-wing discourse: grandiose and contemptuous, disingenuous and self-contradictory, with the necessary undertone of self-pity as justification. Alito, like the five other conservative justices, was placed on the Court by the conservative legal movement for the purpose of someday handing down this decision. These justices are doing what they were put there to do.

College can't level the playing field by itself (opinion)

The biggest loss for college opportunity with the demise of the Build Back Better Act is not free community college. It is the provisions for expanded child tax credits, investments in childcare and universal preschool. Investing in children is the only way to develop young people who are prepared to reap the full benefits of a college education.

The Language of Training | NickerNews

Understanding the language of training, I believe, can help bring us to a larger, more ecological view of ourselves as one of many creatures in the world—a world in which we are not the only makers and interpreter of signs.  For we too are being read and interpreted by those other creatures that surround us, often without our knowing.  We rarely pay attention, rarely listen to the many voices out there to hear what they are saying, and we rarely stop to think what it is we might be saying to them, without intending to, or even knowing that we are saying anything.

Opinion | Democrats, You Can’t Ignore the Culture Wars Any Longer - The New York Times

These are not just attacks on individual teachers and schools; they don’t stigmatize just vulnerable children and their communities; they are the foundation for an assault on the very idea of public education, part of the long war against public goods and collective responsibility fought by conservatives on behalf of hierarchy and capital.

The Review: Conceptual, Cunning, and Conclusive — What Psychology Isn’t

“Psychology,” they write in their abstract, “is fundamentally incompatible with hypothesis-driven theoretical science,” a model whose ideal is physics. Psychologists might pretend to engage in the deductive discovery of general laws, but in fact their “theories are not clearly tied to observational outcomes,” their “hypotheses cannot discriminate between theories,” and their “conclusions from the lab do not translate to scenarios of intrinsic interest.”

The Philosopher Queens

The trouble is not, of course, men as such — men have done good enough philosophy in the past — what is wrong is a particular style of philosophizing that results from encouraging a lot of clever young men to compete in winning arguments ... By contrast, in those wartime classes — which were small — men (conscientious objectors etc.) were present as well as women but they weren’t keen on arguing. It is clear that we all were more interested in understanding this deeply puzzling world than in putting each other down.

Should Universities Take Political Stands?

If one believes that the purpose of higher education is not limited to “teaching and research” but also includes preparation for “public participation in democracy and civic life” — a common though not universally held view — then the university must consider how and when, as in institution of great privilege and influence, it models that participation.

October 2021 – Roth on Wesleyan

Academic freedom is at the core of our mission. The ability of students and teachers to speak their minds, to inquire widely over difficult and disturbing subjects is fundamental to a liberal education. There are times when we must step in to protect members of our community from harassment or intimidation – when we must protect “safe enough spaces” so that academic freedom and open inquiry can continue. Most of the time, though, we can exercise resilience, vigilance, and care so as to nurture the freedom of ongoing teaching, artistic practice, and research. We learn from that exercise habits of mind and spirit that are relevant far beyond the borders of the university.

Roth on Wesleyan – Michael S. Roth became Wesleyan University's 16th president on July 1, 2007.

Today, higher-ed institutions need more (not less) diversity broadly conceived ― including intellectual diversity ― and we should enhance our efforts to make them inclusive, dynamic places of learning through difference. A retreat from affirmative action will result in more “opportunity hoarding,” and return us to the orchestrated parochialism of the past.

Book review of Trapped in the Present Tense: Meditations on American Memory by Colette Brooks - The Washington Post

We turn to the past sometimes for accurate, objective accounts, and sometimes to glean lessons we can apply to the future. And sometimes we turn to the past simply so that it won’t disappear; we pay attention to it because it was meaningful to us, and we acknowledge that meaning with reverence. Paying one’s respects to the past, through memorialization of some kind, is an act of piety.

Black History Month Has Ended and The Past Continues to Haunt Us – Roth on Wesleyan

let us stand in solidarity to defend the right to vote by supporting voter registration efforts across the country. Colleges and universities should inspire their students to take the field, as in the Freedom Summer of 1964, to help people participate in the electoral process. Librarians and other educators should stand shoulder-to-shoulder to stop the banning of books just because they cause discomfort. Professors and administrators should make common cause to defend the right to discuss uncomfortable subjects and to explore new visions of American history and Black history.

Art and Culture in Schorske’s Century - Public Books

At Wesleyan, Schorske’s understanding of history was expanded, and he began to bring together the relations of politics and culture. This was enabled by long discussions of scholarship, culture, and politics with two of his friends at the time. One of them was Herbert Marcuse, a philosopher, sociologist, and political theorist who had just written Eros and Civilization: A Philosophical Inquiry into Freud (1955), and the other was Norman O. Brown, a classicist and Freudian.

Yale-NUS Is Bringing Liberal-Arts Education to Asia - The Atlantic

My highest aspiration for the new “American-style” college in Singapore is the aspiration that Walker and Du Bois, Addams and Dewey had for liberal education: to promote freedom as a good in itself and to be a vehicle for expanding individuals’ knowledge of themselves and the world.

Yale-NUS Is Bringing Liberal-Arts Education to Asia - The Atlantic

Liberal education in American history has often been powerful because it has challenged the status quo. Liberal education today that is worthy of the name must recover the capacity to be untimely so as to equip teachers and students with the courage and the ability to resist the demand for the narrowly vocational.

Remembering 9/11 Twenty Years Later – Roth on Wesleyan

For me, this sad anniversary is an occasion for piety, and I take some consolation in communal remembrance. Going forward, I’d like to think that by discovering ways of joining with others to provide security without making war, we are doing our best to remember all the victims of 9/11 and its aftermath

Book review of DSM: A History of Psychiatry's Bible by Allan V. Horwitz - The Washington Post

Each group of changemakers thinks it is being scientific, but, as Horwitz’s subtitle suggests, they are more like fundamentalists trying to convert others to their way of seeing the world. And just as learning about the history of the texts that compose the Bible makes it harder to take the Good Book seriously as the literal word of God, so reading this history of how the DSM was put together makes it harder to sustain faith in scientific progress in psychiatry.

Pairagraph - Notable Dialogue

The purpose of a college education, in my view, is not to learn how to disparage or convert those with whom one disagrees, nor is it to learn how to embrace more tightly those who share one’s “universal” beliefs in the “pearl of great price.” You can get such pearls through faith (or grace), but this is not what a university is for. A college education should not require religious devotion, and it does not aim only for a “life of study.”

The War on History Is a War on Democracy - The New York Times

The memory management enables the voter suppression. The history of denying Black people the vote is shameful. This means that it is less likely to be taught where teachers are mandated to protect young people from feeling shame. The history of denying Black people the vote involves law and society. This means that it is less likely to be taught where teachers are mandated to tell students that racism is only personal prejudice.